Will AI Replace Human Resources?

The proliferation of artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming industries worldwide, and HR and talent acquisition are no exception. The visions of an AI-augmented future are sparking spirited debates across departments and teams, fostering both hope and caution about the potential and pitfalls of this emerging technology.

The Current State of AI in HR

In recent dialogues with leaders spanning HR, L&D, talent, and the C-suite, one theme emerges unmistakably: the surge of HR's alignment with AI innovation. Professionals are eagerly tuning their strategies to harness new AI capabilities, but there's palpable anxiety too. Concerns revolve around identifying genuine use cases, ensuring return on investment, navigating ethical quandaries, and grappling with the rapid pace of the field's evolution. There's a general consensus that while some organizations are gearing up to make a major AI push in 2024, others are already pioneering AI applications even amid challenging financial climates. Interestingly, many organizations still lack a solid AI manifesto, highlighting the industry-wide learning curve that persists.

AI and Its Implications on HR Jobs

The mounting influence of AI in HR has prompted discussions about its potential to replace human roles. Yet, the predominant perspective is that AI will act more as an enabler than a replacement. Historically, the integration of AI into the HR domain has been impressive. A significant portion of organizations piloting or already using AI have applied it in HR. In fact, 20% of the more than 600 HR professionals who responded to the latest State of HR survey said that they plan on investing in AI/machine learning; it came second only to career pathing. A whopping 70% said AI will significantly impact Human Resources.

This trend has triggered speculations: will AI overshadow HR roles in the future? For many, AI is perceived as a catalyst for large-scale automation, particularly for roles centered around repetitive, process-driven tasks. However, the more strategic facets of HR, such as recruitment planning and executive coaching, are seen as domains where the human touch remains irreplaceable. Nonetheless, the undeniable reality is that AI will introduce changes, and some roles might even become obsolete. High-volume tasks with low decision complexity are particularly susceptible to AI integration.

Watch this panel discuss how AI is already impacting HR.

Specific HR Jobs Impacted by AI

Several HR jobs have a mix of repetitive tasks and critical decisions that necessitate human judgment. For instance, recruiters often sift through vast quantities of resumes, shortlist candidates, and arrange interviews. While this process is time-intensive and could be optimized by AI, the human touch is essential for effectively engaging candidates throughout the hiring journey.

AI has significant potential, so this is just a few of the ways it may impact HR. To give a flavor, here's a sneak peek at only a handful of examples where AI has substantial potential, if implemented well:

Automated Resume Screening: Large corporations receive an overwhelming number of resumes for every job vacancy. AI can assist in this challenge in many ways, such as pre-shortlisting vast numbers of candidates due to likely skills fit and experience. While AI bias is often voiced as a serious concern, and it is indeed a concern, control mechanisms for these systems are also relatively simple to implement and monitor. Thus, AI has the potential to be far less biased than humans, a statement backed up by a vast array of research into unconscious bias in human decision-making, a real opportunity.

Passive Candidate Sourcing: In a competitive hiring landscape, AI can automatically scan publicly available information to curate lists of potential candidates, as well as initiate initial outreach to scope out interest in new roles. Such active outreach efforts can also reduce time spent on candidates who actively tailor their public profile with every application in order to fit as best as possible the role they are currently applying for, as well as reduce recruitment fees.

AI-Driven Pre-Hire Assessments: AI-led video analysis has the potential to revolutionize pre-hire assessments, where an organization sees a fit to do part of this process digitally. Candidates can engage at their own convenience and timing, and AI can also support in analyzing candidates for further shortlisting.

Enhanced Employee Engagement Surveys: Automating employee engagement surveys through AI can save HR hundreds of hours yearly, potentially increase participation rates, streamline survey distribution, and support the key outcome: analysis and personalized follow-ups. AI can enable HR to focus more on interpreting the feedback and crafting timely strategies and actions as visible and tangible outcomes from such efforts.

Optimized Workforce Scheduling: AI could transform workforce scheduling by creating schedules that align with employee preferences and ensure compliance with labor laws. Real-time adjustments and alerts could also be managed seamlessly.

Watch Markus Bernhardt share his thoughts on AI at a recent event.

Preparing for the Future

AI's integration into HR is undeniable. However, the future is unlikely to see "HR robots" replacing human HR professionals. The real shift lies in reallocating administrative tasks toward AI, allowing HR professionals to focus on strategic, value-added activities. The future of HR will pivot toward new priorities, such as choosing the right workplace technology and bolstering the employer brand.

Key Considerations for AI in Business

Start Simple: It's crucial to choose specific AI use cases that align with clear business deliverables. While having a long-term vision is essential, it's equally vital to make steady, incremental progress. What are the main pain points or opportunities to bring in new, AI powered solutions and approaches? 

Stay Updated: The pace of technological advancement is relentless. Professionals must keep abreast of the latest tools, innovations, and best practices, possibly through communities of practice, where shared learning can occur. While practitioners need to stay on top of developments around tools for everyday use, leadership teams need to ensure a solid understanding of generative and non-generative AI, current strengths and weaknesses of models, and a solid understanding of potential synergies and opportunities supporting their current business strategy. Separating the hype from the reality is going to be key, for years to come.

Ethical Use of AI: It's imperative to have an AI manifesto that resonates with widely accepted ethical guidelines. Each organization must strike a balance, with some erring on the side of caution and others being more adventurous.

Consider Company Culture: The application of AI must be in sync with an organization's culture. For instance, an organization emphasizing human interaction might send mixed signals if it heavily automates the interview process, irrespective of the availability of such tools.

What’s Next?

As AI continues to reshape the HR and business landscape, professionals must embrace the challenges and opportunities it presents. Continuous learning and adaptation are paramount. It's crucial to remember that AI is just one tool among many. Using it judiciously, in alignment with organizational culture and goals, can unlock immense potential and drive meaningful change.

Join the global human resources online community

Join HR Exchange Network today and interact with a vibrant network of professionals, keeping up to date with the industry by accessing our wealth of articles, videos, live conferences and more.

Join Now

Photo by Michelangelo Buonarroti for Pexels